Skip to main content

Table 2 Mean difference and correlation coefficient of food intakes between 24hR-camera and WFR in 30 Japanese men

From: Validation of improved 24-hour dietary recall using a portable camera among the Japanese population

 

24hR-camera

WFR

Difference:

24hR-camera

- WFR

Pb

Correlation coefficient

95% Limits of agreementc

Food category (g)

Mean ± SD

Mean ± SD

Mean difference (%)a

 

Spearman

(95%CI)

01: Cereals

553.5 ± 139.5

589.5 ± 143.1

-6.1

0.053

0.783 (0.589, 0.892)

-227.4 (-39.8)

155.6 (27.2)

02: Potatoes and Starches

54.3 ± 63.5

69.7 ± 92.5

-22.1

0.160

0.897 (0.793, 0.950)

-130.2 (-210.1)

99.4 (160.3)

03: Sugars and Sweeteners

5.5 ± 7.1

4.6 ± 4.8

21.1

0.329

0.514 (0.189, 0.738)

-9.4 (-187.1)

11.3 (225.2)

04: Pulses

63.1 ± 62.8

66.7 ± 63.4

-5.4

0.637

0.764 (0.557, 0.882)

-84.7 (-130.5)

77.5 (119.4)

05: Nuts and Seeds

3.8 ± 12.1

3.9 ± 12.4

-2.2

0.891

0.719 (0.484, 0.857)

-6.6 (-171.9)

6.4 (167.5)

06: Vegetables

336.2 ± 132.1

372.0 ± 111.7

-9.6

0.045

0.738 (0.515, 0.868)

-218.8 (-61.8)

147.3 (41.6)

07: Fruits

77.6 ± 80.9

86.6 ± 83.4

-10.4

0.157

0.906 (0.810, 0.955)

-75.5 (-92.0)

57.5 (70.0)

08: Mushrooms

29.8 ± 44.6

31.2 ± 35.3

-4.2

0.805

0.889 (0.778, 0.946)

-58.0 (-190.2)

55.4 (181.6)

09: Algae

10.0 ± 12.8

6.4 ± 9.7

56.3

0.052

0.855 (0.715, 0.929)

-15.5 (-188.6)

22.7 (276.5)

10: Fishes and Shellfishes

75.0 ± 57.3

81.3 ± 60.4

-7.7

0.317

0.852 (0.710, 0.928)

-72.6 (-92.9)

60.0 (76.8)

11: Meats

96.6 ± 63.7

101.4 ± 64.5

-4.8

0.272

0.946 (0.889, 0.974)

-51.2 (-51.7)

41.5 (41.9)

12:Eggs

53.5 ± 44.7

50.7 ± 37.4

5.5

0.429

0.865 (0.733, 0.934)

-34.7 (-66.5)

40.3 (77.3)

13: Dairy Products

88.2 ± 101.7

101.6 ± 112.4

-13.2

0.053

0.970 (0.937, 0.986)

-84.4 (-88.9)

57.6 (60.7)

14: Fats and oils

14.5 ± 10.4

12.8 ± 9.0

13.1

0.356

0.533 (0.214, 0.749)

-17.5 (-128.7)

20.9 (153.4)

15: Confectioneries

18.3 ± 37.8

18.2 ± 38.4

0.6

0.871

0.969 (0.935, 0.985)

-6.5 (-35.5)

6.7 (36.6)

16: Beverages

673.6 ± 382.8

661.3 ± 357.4

1.9

0.399

0.955 (0.907, 0.979)

-142.1 (-21.3)

166.7 (25.0)

17: Seasonings and Spices

176.2 ± 135.3

153.3 ± 148.5

15.0

0.448

0.465 (0.126, 0.707)

-297.1 (-180.3)

342.9 (208.1)

  1. SD standard deviation, CI confidence interval
  2. aPersentage of mean difference between 24hR-camera and WFR in each food category (calculated as: % of the difference = (mean amount from 24hR-camera—mean amount from WFR)/ mean amount from WFR)*100)
  3. bpaired t-test
  4. c95% linits of agreenment for the difference between 24hR-camera and WFR, in the corresponding units for each food group and percentage in parenthesis, show the range of under and over-estimation for the agreement between both methods
  5. See also Fig. 2